WEEKEND · AFTERNOON
TOMORROW: THE CASE THAT COULD END SUITS AGAINST FEDERAL AGENTS
The Supreme Court hears arguments Monday, Nov. 9, in Nielsen v. Watanabe — a case that could end suits against federal officers. Kekai Watanabe was attacked in a 2021 gang fight at the Federal Detention Center in Honolulu, suffering a fractured coccyx. He alleges nurse Francis Nielsen gave him only over-the-counter pain medication and never sent him to a hospital. His $3 million suit rests on Bivens, the 1971 ruling that lets people sue federal officers for constitutional violations. The 9th Circuit let his Eighth Amendment claim proceed. Nielsen's lawyers call Bivens a relic Congress never authorized and ask the court to overrule it. The Justice Department calls the 1980 precedent behind the claim 'obsolete.' Watanabe's lawyers say Congress ratified these suits in 1996.
Who should decide if you can sue a federal agent — the courts or Congress?