THE DEBATE · PRIMETIME
2-1: 27 TROOPS STAY. THE BAN FIGHT GOES TO THE SUPREME COURT
A D.C. Circuit panel voted 2-1 Tuesday to let its June ruling in Talbott v. USA take effect immediately, blocking the Pentagon from discharging the transgender troops who sued over the ban. The order covers 27 troops with 130+ years of combined service and 80+ commendations, per plaintiffs' attorneys. It does not reopen enlistment — new recruits stay barred, and a Supreme Court petition is pending.
Judge Wilkins wrote the administration has not shown how retaining the troops would cause irreparable harm or endanger national security. The administration argues its policy, which presumptively disqualifies people with gender dysphoria, protects readiness. Judge Walker, dissenting, said judges lack the power to second-guess the exclusion. A Hegseth spokesperson declined to comment.
Who decides who can serve — the Pentagon, or the courts?