THE DEBATE · PRIMETIME
BURGUM: HISTORIC STEP. EARTHJUSTICE: RENEGADE, UNLAWFUL.
The Trump administration held the first-ever U.S. deep-sea mining lease sale Thursday, selling two areas totaling about 31 million acres off American Samoa for $6 million — three days after Judge Jill Otake ruled the fisheries service violated the Endangered Species Act, failing to even attempt to consider effects on listed species.
Who waits: American Samoans. Their governor opposes extraction, the territory banned mining in its waters in 2024, and the leases sit near Rose Atoll, home to whales, turtles and coral. The 20-year leases allow preliminary work only; mining needs further reviews.
Secretary Doug Burgum calls it a historic step for mineral security. Earthjustice attorney Chris Eaton calls it a renegade, unlawful act and vows to push to void the leases.
Should a court ruling have paused this sale?